finisar
March 9th, 2009

Testing Challenges for FCoE

Migrating to FCoE sounds good on paper, but a key concern for network administrators is how to protect existing network performance when FCoE moves in.  In the past, network planners brought in expensive Fibre Channel equipment because of the guarantees it provided through its dedicated link architecture: guaranteed performance, guaranteed latency, and guaranteed robustness.  Ethernet is well-known for not providing these guarantees. 

In order for network administrators to feel confident enough to migrate to FCoE, they will need to be able to test and verify real-world performance against the marketing claims of FCoE equipment manufacturers.  For example, the IEEE FCoE standards being developed provide delivery guarantees, better latency performance, and higher bandwidth utilization.  While the standard drafts are as good as they sound, developers and administrators still need a way to verify that a particular implementation has been successful in meeting latency requirements. 

Likewise, administrators will need to be able to verify end-to-end performance.  An FCoE link is comprised of an Ethernet link accessing Fibre Channel storage.  Measuring performance up to the transition point fails to take into account all of the unexpected foibles of what happens when crossing protocol domains.  Developers and administrators need to be able to prove performance end-to-end; it’s simply too important a decision to leave to trust or assumption.  

Finally, key to generating sales of FCoE is the ability to compare native Fibre Channel to FCoE implementations.  Disruptive technologies need to not only reduce cost compared to incumbent technologies, they also need to provide greater functionality and/or benefit in order to overcome the inertia of the market buying what it is already used to.  Hard numbers will always sell more than wordy promises. 

Reaching the technological milestones of FCoE is important, but being able to prove value is what will carry FCoE to market successfully.


Leave a Reply